Community Backlash as Fred Caterson Reserve Sports Field Construction Nears

Tensions are running high in Castle Hill as construction nears for the long-debated $16.6 million redevelopment of Fred Caterson Reserve into what many are calling an “elite rugby precinct.” Residents and community groups are furious, arguing the project will limit community access and threaten the reserve’s sensitive bushland.

Resident Backlash

Local resident Susan Sandercock, a member of the Fred Caterson Action Group, said the community feels ignored. “This isn’t what locals were promised — our open community spaces are being handed over for elite use,” she said.

The Hills Shire Council recently awarded the construction tender for three new rugby fields to serve as a home base for the Eastwood District Rugby Union Football Club. While the council says the facility will also be open to community use, opponents fear the upgrade will prioritise club activities over local recreation.

At a recent council meeting, Cr Mila Kasby said public feedback opposing the masterplan had been “disregarded,” calling it “a complete mockery of the democratic process.” Cr Tina Cartwright said the draft /generic plan misrepresents public feedback and undermines community consultation.

Council’s Response

Defending the decision, Cr Samuel Uno stated that the council has worked closely with NSW Crown Lands — the site’s owner — to ensure all plans align with state requirements. He stressed that the plan of management remains “generic,” not a specific commitment to a premier rugby precinct at this stage.

Despite this, residents remain unconvinced, with Fred Caterson Champions Inc launching legal action in the Land and Environment Court to halt works.

Mayor and Club Defend Project

Mayor Dr Michelle Byrne welcomed the start of construction, calling the project essential to address a severe shortage of sporting fields in The Hills. “Our shire needs at least 40 additional fields to meet the demands of our growing population,” she said.

A council spokesperson added that the fields will be available for public use when not booked by clubs, and that the project includes environmental safeguards to preserve the reserve’s natural character.

Eastwood Rugby Manager Robert Frost said the redevelopment would benefit thousands of players and supporters across the region. “This is a wonderful site full of potential. We’ll always respect its heritage while embracing the opportunities ahead,” he said.

The Vision Ahead

The proposed enhancements under the Fred Caterson Reserve Masterplan could include upgraded change rooms, gym facilities, club rooms, food and beverage outlets, merchandise areas, spectator seating, and improved lighting.

While construction is set to begin soon, the battle over who truly benefits — the elite or the everyday community — shows no sign of ending.